The Ben Moi / Kibogy Farm Dispute: Land, Violence, and Historical Claims in Moiben
By William Kiptoo
The Ben Moi Farm dispute, also written Benmoi or Ben-Moi and known as the Kibogy Farm dispute, is one of the most bitter land conflicts in Uasin Gishu County. The farm lies in Moiben, and the dispute has run for more than three decades. It has twice turned violent, during attempts to evict the occupants in 2015. Beyond the question of who owns one farm, it reflects the wider history of land in the Rift Valley, where colonial dispossession, post-independence settlement and weak land administration have left generations uncertain of their place.
The land is L.R. No. 8319, a farm of 2,098 acres according to the court record, though the press has often described it as about 2,000 acres. It is registered to Kibogy Properties Limited, a company of the Kibogy family. The family says the land was lawfully bought by the late John Kiplagat Kibogy, named in press reports as Jonathan Kibogy, and the courts have repeatedly upheld the company's title. About seventy-five workers and former workers of earlier owners, with their families, live on the farm and say it is their home.
The title history goes back to the colonial settlement of the former White Highlands. According to the 2014 judgment of the Environment and Land Court, the land was held under a 999-year lease from 1 August 1955. A settler, William Dudley Owen, farmed it in the mid-1960s, and in 1967 it passed to Lands Limited, a company of the Agricultural Development Corporation. Mr Kibogy leased the farm from 1970, bought it in 1978 for KSh 783,540 with the consent of the Land Control Board, and the transfer to Kibogy Properties was registered on 29 September 1994.
The occupants tell the story differently. Their witnesses told the court that they, or their parents, were employees of the settlers and later of the Agricultural Development Corporation, and that about 800 workers had once lived in six camps on the farm. One of the claimants, William Lusweti Nabiswa, was said to have come to the farm in 1948 as a driver for a settler named Taylor, who, they said, left the farm to him at independence. The court found no record that a Mr Taylor ever held title to the land. Over time the workers' camps grew into a settled community with homes, graves and cultivated fields.
The Kibogy family regards the occupants as former workers with no claim to ownership. Kiptoo Kibogy, the late owner's son and the administrator of his estate, told The Standard that his father bought the land and paid for it in full. The company told the court that it cultivates about 1,600 acres.
The case began on 21 December 1990, when 75 occupants filed a claim in the High Court at Nairobi for the land by adverse possession, which is ownership gained through long, open occupation. The case moved through several courts and about ten firms of lawyers before judgment on 30 October 2014. Justice Munyao Sila held that the occupants had entered and stayed on the farm as employees, so they were licensees, and that time for adverse possession cannot run against an owner who gave permission. He found no fraud proved and held the title valid. He said he sympathised with the occupants, but that the law was not on their side.
On 17 March 2015 the court allowed Kibogy Properties to evict the occupants after thirty days. The Court of Appeal refused to stop the eviction on 8 May 2015, noting that the occupants had not shown their appeal was filed in time.
Two violent clashes followed, both reported in the press. In the first, The Standard reported that a private developer backed by police and youths came to evict the occupants, who drove them off with bows and arrows and burned a vehicle; a police officer and several civilians were injured. In the second, in late May 2015, the Eldoret East police commander said officers came under fire, that one officer was shot in the leg and that police shot and killed one man. He said the occupants had AK-47 rifles and that four people had been arrested. The occupants' account of how the shooting began was not reported. The Standard also reported that machinery and vehicles worth more than KSh 15 million were burned, and that local residents who sided with the police burned more than 50 houses. These figures are the newspaper's, not official counts, and no court has examined these events.
Muhammad Swazuri, then chairman of the National Land Commission, toured the farm and urged the occupants to obey the court orders and avoid violence, The Star reported on 2 June 2015.
The claim did not end there. In 2016 the occupants complained to the National Land Commission, which summoned Kibogy Properties to review its title. On 28 June 2018 the Environment and Land Court stopped the Commission from reopening a dispute the court had already decided. In 2023 Wellington Barasa, acting for his father William Lusweti Nabiswa, filed a fresh suit seeking ownership. On 30 April 2024 the court struck it out as a matter already decided and an abuse of the court process.
The dispute shows the gap between legal ownership and long occupation in Kenya's land conflicts. The Kibogy family relies on its title and on the court judgments, and argues that failing to enforce them undermines the rule of law. The occupants see the dispute through their history on the farm, where generations have been born, worked and buried, and believe that this history gives them a moral claim that a court order does not erase. The courts have decided the legal question in favour of the title holder. The social question of what happens to the families remains.
Several things are still not known: whether the 2015 eviction order was fully carried out and how many families remain on the farm; whether anyone was charged over the 2015 killing, the injuries and the burning of vehicles and houses; the name of the man who was killed; and whether any appeal against the 2014 judgment was ever heard. If you have documents or memories of Ben Moi Farm, please share them. Anyone named here who believes something is wrong or incomplete is welcome to contact me, and corrections will be made.
Map showing Benmoi Farm as marked on Google Maps, in Moiben, Uasin Gishu County. The farm's boundaries are not shown. Map data: Google.
Sources
- Wellington Lusweti Barasa & 75 others v Lands Limited & another, [2014] KEELC 110 (KLR), judgment of 30 October 2014
- Wellington Lusweti Baraza & 47 others v Lands Limited & Kibogy Properties Ltd, [2015] KEELC 384 (KLR), ruling of 17 March 2015
- Wellington Lusweti Barasa & 47 Others v Lands Ltd & Another, [2015] KECA 11 (KLR), 8 May 2015
- Republic v National Land Commission & 75 others, ex parte Kibogy Properties Limited, [2018] KEELC 2540 (KLR), 28 June 2018
- Barasa v Kibogy (Administrator of John Kiplagat Kibogy) & another, [2024] KEELC 3903 (KLR), 30 April 2024
- The Standard, Police officer, residents injured as eviction mission backfires, 2015
- The Standard, One person killed, police officer injured in clash with squatters in Moiben, Uasin Gishu, 2015
- The Star, Swazuri tours disputed 2,000 acres Ben-Moi farm in Eldoret, 2 June 2015
- William Kiptoo, Ben Moi (Kibogy) Farm, Moiben: 2,098 Acres, a 1990 Claim and the Courts' Verdict, Journeys of a Peace Worker
William Kiptoo writes about peace, land and memory at Journeys of a Peace Worker.
Comments
Post a Comment